Nagorno-Karabakh – The winner’s responsibility – The Weekly 144

Márton Gyöngyösi

30/09/2023

Earlier this week the president of the ethnic Armenian breakaway Nagorno-Karabakh territory signed the directive for all the Armenian authorities and institutions of Nagorno Karabakh to be dissolved by January 1 2024, with the territory returning to Azerbaijan’s rule. After a tragic war going on for over thirty years, this event marks the end of the conflict (hopefully at least).

Unfortunately, we have no reason to be overly optimistic; the settlement of the Karabakh issue still seems far from a happy end. 

Massive waves of the Armenian population have been fleeing from Karabakh, and the Azerbaijani authorities have been making vague and controversial statements about the area’s future.

It is a fact that Karabakh and the surrounding territories were occupied in violation of international law amidst the Soviet Union’s collapse, and the local Azeri population was driven away against all norms of humanity. Nagorno Karabakh’s Armenian authorities clearly had a responsibility in the destruction of villages and towns.

However, it does not provide any grounds for Azerbaijan to take revenge on Karabakh’s Armenian population now, thirty years later. 

Responsibility clearly lies with the winner. Now we and the European Union must remind Baku that the restoration of territorial integrity and sovereignty does not grant an unlimited mandate. The norms of international law must still be respected under any circumstances.

We must make it clear that just as Azerbaijan has the right to its own territory, Karabakh Armenians also have the right to live in their homeland and preserve their linguistic and religious legacy. 

Furthermore, Nagorno-Karabakh was already an autonomous republic within Azerbaijan during the Soviet times – although we do have our suspicions as to what such autonomy exactly meant back then; its symbolic value is nonetheless significant.

So, Azerbaijan is absolutely rightfully expected to guarantee the territorial autonomy and collective rights of Karabakh Armenians as well as to treat the area differently from its other territories. It is a key condition, not only for the survival of local Armenians but for the peace and stability of the Caucasus region, too.

 

Related Articles

It’s time for Europe to take control of her own security – The Weekly 152

It’s time for Europe to take control of her own security – The Weekly 152

Historically, the past seventy years were a special era for Western Europe, and the same applies to the past thirty years for Central Europe as well. Our continent was able to focus on her own business and become one of the world’s wealthiest regions without having to deal much with security, as it was outsourced to the United States of America.

read more
Where is the limit for the freedom of speech? – The Weekly 150

Where is the limit for the freedom of speech? – The Weekly 150

The European Parliament’s December plenary session was to debate a serious matter on its agenda. The submitted report urged the European Union to lay down universal norms in terms of hate speech and hate crimes. However, the report was eventually not submitted for voting – under mysterious circumstances.

read more